How Arson and Fire Investigation Tests Claim Denials

How Arson and Fire Investigation Tests Claim Denials

November 17, 2026

A defensible origin analysis connects fire science, preserved evidence and reliable timelines to the coverage issues counsel must assess.

Back to blog home

When a fire claim is disputed


You are reviewing a fire claim denial, but the stated cause may not match the physical evidence. A thorough arson and fire investigation can show whether an incendiary conclusion rests on tested facts or assumptions. Counsel can then assess the origin-and-cause process, admissibility risks, evidence controls and supporting records that strengthen or undermine the carrier’s position.

What the insurer must prove in Michigan


In a Michigan insurance dispute, an insurer asserting arson or intentional loss as an affirmative defense generally bears the burden of proving that defense by a preponderance of the evidence. A suspicious-looking fire or the absence of an immediately identified accidental source is not enough on its own.


The analysis usually separates three questions: Was the fire incendiary? Did the insured have a motive? Did the insured have an opportunity to set or procure the fire? Origin evidence addresses the first question. Financial records, access evidence and witness accounts may bear on the others. One category should not substitute for another.


An undetermined origin does not, by itself, establish an intentional act. If viable accidental causes remain untested, the evidence supporting an exclusion may be incomplete. Conversely, separate non-communicating origins, a timing device, tampered utilities or laboratory-confirmed ignitable-liquid residue can support further inquiry into motive and opportunity.

Moving from hypothesis to physical evidence


A reliable scene examination proceeds systematically rather than beginning with a preferred theory. Detroit-based Bleu Wing Investigations, Inc. conducts technical origin-and-cause fire scene examinations throughout Michigan for legal counsel and insurance review, examining origin, liability and evidence of potential incendiary acts.


The physical examination normally progresses from the exterior to the interior and from areas of lesser damage towards greater damage. Investigators document ventilation openings, structural conditions, fire effects and suppression activity. Within the suspected origin area, debris may be removed layer by layer so damaged wiring, appliances, fuel packages and ignition sources retain their spatial context.


Burn patterns are data points, not automatic answers. Lines of demarcation, soot deposits, char, gypsum damage and V-shaped patterns must be assessed against fire duration, ventilation, fuel load and possible flashover. An intense pattern can identify heat exposure without proving what first ignited.


A scientific analysis develops and tests separate accidental, natural and incendiary hypotheses. Each proposed cause should fit the scene evidence and known fire dynamics; a cause is not established merely because several alternatives were eliminated. Our origin-and-cause investigation services focus on this technical fact-finding role.


Investigator examining charring patterns on exposed wooden studs inside a fire-damaged room.


Testing the method under MRE 702


Method can decide whether an origin opinion remains useful in litigation. According to Michigan Courts, MRE 702 requires the proponent to show that expert testimony rests on sufficient facts or data, reliable principles and methods, and a reliable application of those methods.


Negative-corpus reasoning is a frequent vulnerability. It occurs when a fire is classified as incendiary because no accidental source was identified, despite a lack of affirmative evidence proving intentional ignition. That conclusion may fail when the scene was heavily damaged, relevant components were removed or reasonable accidental hypotheses were not tested.


Outdated rules of thumb create similar problems. Low burning, concrete spalling, deep char or irregular floor patterns are not conclusive proof of an ignitable liquid. Flashover, radiant heat, ventilation and falling burning material can produce comparable effects.


Counsel should also examine whether the report distinguishes observations from inferences, identifies contrary evidence and explains why competing hypotheses were rejected. MRE 703 creates a further issue when the facts or data underlying an opinion are not admitted at trial. Unverified witness statements should not quietly become scientific premises.

Chain of custody in arson and fire investigation


Once evidence is altered, moved or discarded, otherwise sound origin reasoning becomes harder to evaluate. Bleu Wing Investigations, Inc. applies discipline developed through 30 years of public law-enforcement experience, including strict legal boundaries, structured photographic logs and rigorous chain-of-custody procedures.


Scene control should include a defined entry point and a log recording each visitor’s identity, affiliation, arrival time and purpose. Before destructive examination, potentially interested parties may need notice and an opportunity to attend a joint inspection. This protects relevant evidence and reduces later spoliation disputes.


Suspected ignitable-liquid debris requires particular care. Samples intended for laboratory analysis are commonly placed in clean, unlined metal cans or dedicated vapor-barrier bags because ordinary polyethylene bags can allow volatile hydrocarbons to escape. A canine alert or field instrument reading can guide sample selection, but confirmatory laboratory analysis is still required.


The custody record should follow every transfer from collection through storage, transport and laboratory receipt. Photographs should show the item before collection, its location, identifying marks, packaging and seal. Our reports use time-stamped visual material and structured records so counsel can trace what was observed, what was collected and who handled it.

Corroborating the scene with records and telemetry


The scene is only one part of the timeline. Independent records can confirm or contradict an origin theory, identify when conditions changed and test witness accounts.

  • Municipal records may include 911 audio, computer-aided dispatch logs, fire incident reports, police records, permits, inspection histories and weather data.
  • Utility records may reveal electrical-load changes, gas use, service interruptions or smart-meter events near the estimated ignition time.
  • Security video, alarm logs, dashcam footage and smart-device histories can establish movement and the sequence of smoke, motion or heat alerts.
  • Maintenance files and electrical diagrams can show whether equipment defects, previous repairs or known building conditions require further examination.

First-responder observations deserve special attention because suppression and ventilation can alter the scene. The U.S. Fire Administration identifies door and window conditions, smoke, flame behavior, odors and suppression actions as relevant investigative information. Those observations should be compared with physical patterns rather than treated as stand-alone proof of cause.


Clean metal evidence collection cans and field equipment resting on a truck tailgate at an investigation site.


Technical documentation counsel can evaluate


Counsel needs a report that makes the reasoning visible. We compile detailed reports for legal review, including structured photographic logs, documented records and a clear account of the investigative process. The file should allow the reader to evaluate the basis for each conclusion rather than rely on unexplained experience.


Independent review should be considered when the initial cause is undetermined, the parties disagree about origin, physical patterns do not fit witness accounts, fraud is suspected or a product, utility or contractor may face potential liability. Retention should occur before cleanup, demolition or repairs destroy the suspected origin area. Our guide to when to retain an independent fire origin investigator explains the preservation concerns in more detail.


For an existing denial, counsel can use the technical file to test whether each conclusion is tied to preserved evidence, whether accidental causes received meaningful consideration and whether the timeline agrees with external records. This review can also expose gaps while additional records or examinations remain available.

Request a confidential case review


Bleu Wing Investigations, Inc. is based in Detroit, MI, and serves counsel throughout Michigan. For an independent origin-and-cause examination or review of a disputed fire file, request a confidential consultation, call or text lead investigator Len directly at (734) 624-1235, or email lenpaquette@gmail.com to discuss the scene, available evidence and preservation needs.

Share this story